Qur'an – Bible.

* Religion * Politics * News Networks * Mainstream Media Biased Reporting * Independent Analysis

Mullahs destroying Islam: Kalbe Sadiq

Posted by QB on November 5, 2006

This is what I am saying since last six year and I am glad to find out that there is someone who have the same understanding. I like this guy.

SENIOR VICE-PRESIDENT of the All India Muslim Personal Law Board (AIMPLB) Dr Kalbe Sadiq today blasted the ‘Mullahs’ for destroying Islam. He said their ill-conceived fatwas (edict) had not only painted Islam in black hues but had also stopped its progress. Dr Sadiq assailed both Shia and Sunni ulema (clerics) for straying away from Quranic path.

Dr Sadiq said Islam laid stress on ‘pen culture’ but Muslims had resorted to ‘gun culture’. Delivering lecture on ‘Islam versus Muslims’ on Sunday, Dr Sadiq said these Mullahs had tarnished the image of Islam in the past and the process was still continuing. He said they had issued ridiculous fatwas, which hampered the progress of the religion.

He said both Sunni and Shia clerics were responsible for present deplorable situation of Muslims. He squarely blamed the ulema for lack of unity in Muslims. Dr Sadiq said these clerics had been fighting among themselves but asking the community to unite. “It is absurd situation”, he said.

Pointing out that Islam was not responsible for the conduct of Muslims, Dr Sadiq said the community had strayed away from intellectual approach and justice. He said Islam did not allow unjust approach against any community.

Dr Sadiq reiterated that birth control was not anti-Islamic, as the religion had laid stress producing good generation and not on degeneration. Dr Sadiq said even though Islam did not permit abortion, it however had not asked the believers to produce child without having resources for his upkeep.

He also attacked Saudi Arabia King Abdullah for his corrupt way of life. He charged chief Mufti of mosque in Medina for resorting to all anti-Islamic activities. Dr Sadiq said history had enough examples that both Shia and Sunni monarch led anti-Islamic life.

He said there had been ulema who even issued fatwas against use of rifles in army or construction of steamship in Turkey. He said Shia ulema had been living lavish life, which was against the tenets of Islam.

Referring to Shia clerics of Lucknow, Dr Sadiq said their participation in luxurious marriages was against Islam. “It is religious crime on their part”, he pontificated and invited the ulema community to debate with him on issues raised by him.

Source: Hindustan Times.

29 Responses to “Mullahs destroying Islam: Kalbe Sadiq”

  1. Mustafa said

    salam un alekum]
    though there is a saying that :answers of fools is silence but if any body attacks ulema there should be answers.we all believe that if a person doesnt likes a thing or want to make changes He himself should be the first.Dr sadiq himself attends these typoes of marriages and those marriages are not enough he has been seen many times having lunch in TAJ with prominent personal;ities.what does he has to say about that what about the doing and richly lives lived by him and his family especially his sons.riding the latest bikes etc ..Dr sadiq please control your family and close reletaives first then say something to others.this is the real sunnah
    wasalam

    • Irani said

      This is all you know what…fact is 63% of Quran is about violence. True that Islamic Republic thugs and Saudi Kings and Princess have damaged Islam…but Islam was never a clean religion to begin with…just a bunch of lies.

  2. Salam Alleikum Mustafa

    I really don’t know who is Dr. Kalbe Sadiq but what he is saying is according to the message of Qur’an. Sunnah and hadiths which contradict Qur’an message must be discarded from the religion and that will be the begining of the much needed reform which are pending from last 1200 years. Sunni and Shia hadiths infact had destroyed the real Islam by emphasizing on dress beards women head covering stoning to death death punishment of apostate which btw were the laws given to Jews. Dr. Kalbe Sadiq is free to spend his money like he wants for which have to answer God on the day of judgement. Dr. Kalbe Sadiq is not saying anything new, the reform movement was started by Allama G. A. Pervez and now there are plenty of people working to bring Muslims back to Qur’an. You can get more information about G. A. Pervez work on their website ToleIslam.com and also watch the video lectures of Mohammad Sheikh quite interesting which makes more sense then these traditionals Mullahs.

    Thanks for you comment.

  3. salam alleikum Mustafa bring reform in yourself rather than commenting on others.We are born as human and so we have necessites in our lives and people like Dr.Sadiq too have to fulfill them. You can’t blame him falselessly just because he is tell you your own drawbacks.If you are just man then do something for you community.
    Why don’t open some institution like Unity College?
    If you have the guts then come up and bring reform instead of weakening your own community.
    people like you can just criticise ,worth nothing…………

  4. Hamid said

    The pervaizi’s have been attacking Islam and Ulema-i-Islam by disrespecting Ulema and stating that all Saheeh Ahaduth are wrong and no rule can be constituted on the base of Hadith.
    They have promoted fake and foolish ideas. They have nothing to do in practical and saying their baseless criticism an ‘Intellectual’ approach.
    LA’NAT ULLAH-e-ALAL KAZIBEEN.

  5. Hamid

    The truth is that the majority of Sunni and Shia Scholars are hypocrite who never answer an intelligent question with straight forward reply. The majority of hadiths are fabricated which created all these sectarian differences. Then there are hadiths which are based on Old Testament and New Testaments which have become the mandatory part of faith and if anyone try to prove them wrong these Scholars declare him apostate. I advice you to read Qur’an and try to understand the meaning of the message.

  6. zainy said

    i agree with dr kalbe sadiq
    people doesnt want to understand islam wht is actually islam , i belong to u.p. n i hav seen people followin islam (or rather the things told by the society)blindly , they doesnt want to explore their own religion , they or u can say we jus observe our religion but do not follow it
    n this kind of drawbacks r ruinin the religion

  7. stevieNI said

    Um can anyone explain the main differences between Islam and Christianity. To me both religions started when a Prophet came down from the heavens and told us about one almighty God. I know im probably really wrong here but I want to learn. ty Stevo

  8. QB said

    Stevie go to religious scholars to learn about religion and they will teach you to hate everybody who does not have the same belief as yours. This blog is more about truth, political or religious not for teaching religion. Take shots at all the three religions Judaism, Christianity, Islam.

  9. Salamalykum

    Dear mustafa and noriya rizvi,

    There is no doubt what Dr.Kalb e sadiq said is right,..specially these words” Dr Sadiq said these clerics had been fighting among themselves but asking the community to unite. “It is absurd situation”,Dr Sadiq said the community had strayed away from intellectual approach and justice. He said Islam did not allow unjust approach against any community.”

    But the question comes who are these corrupt ulema and who will decide who is corrupt? which mulla destroying Islam?

    Those who live in Lucknow these conflicts are very old between two
    “zahniyat” two plateform of ulema and there is no solution of it because both believe they are on right path….
    Regarding purchasing property….please make enquiry who purchased more land in lucknow and why? for community or for their kids??

    My stand is…both are right……let them fight..take what is according to holy quran and practice of ahlulbayt….and enjoy…
    few months back i had written an article when scholars fight….which you can read in my blob…http://alqaim.info/unity.

    wassalam
    S.M.Masoom

  10. QB said

    Mustafa Mohammad Masoom,

    The unity is only possible with carefully revising Sunni Shia hadiths. According to Sunnis and Shias I might be Apostate. The punishment for Apostacy is death, according to hadiths. After reviewing some of your posts briefly decided not to say anything which might hurt your feelings. My advice, get rid of sectarian hatred by opening your mind.

  11. Dear QB..Yeh proper study of all muslims hadith books is necessary but for perfecting your imaan not for islamic unity…

    for unity it is sufficient that we are muslims following same quran and same messenger of Allah(s.a)….

    Your words “sectarian hatred” is an allegation from a muslim to other muslim….for muslim unity we must first take precaution while comment our other muslim brother…..

    This is islam and nothing hurts me as i know we all speak and judge others by our knowledge..and it also changes….
    you are welcome to raise your questions ion my blogs anywhere in any post and i will reply from the holy Quran only……..

    wassalam

  12. Dear QB…i strongly believe in…
    “O you who believe! obey Allah and obey the Messenger and those in authority from among you; then if you quarrel about anything, refer it to Allah and the Messenger, if you believe in Allah and the last day; this is better and very good in the end.” (4:59)

    I am leaving you two weighty things, if you follow them you will never go astray, they are the Qur�an and my Ahlul’bayt�.
    Sahih al-Tirmidhi, v5, page 662-663
    Regarding hadith i say which contradicts the Quran is discarded” and these are not my words but is a hadith of holy prophet(s.a.w)..

    Islam is a philosophy of life. It gives reasons and a set purpose for living. Furthermore, it defines the best ways to secure progress and happiness. This is done by elevating the spiritual side and satisfying the material needs of people.

    Islam considers man as a viceroy of God on earth. This status is a fine one, but it is also critical for the requirements must be satisfied. Thus, he is in an envied position, and consequently his acts and behavior are expected to conform with the high level he is occupying.

    The Islamic concepts and laws are inseparable parts of the Islamic ideology. They are the practical expression of Islam in society and life in general. These concepts and laws are essentially concerned with harmonizing people’s relationships among themselves, with other beings, and above all with the Creator.

  13. QB said

    Dear Friend,
    The “Sectarian Hatred” was not directed at you. It is my general observation that there is strong hatred between Sunnis and Shias. Look what is happening in Iraq, they are killing each other, sectarian hatred is too strong when you look at Muslim world. Which is shameful.

  14. Nazish said

    Salam

    Dr.Kalbe Sadiq is not only a brilliant well read scholar but a bold one who is not afraid to speak out the truth. Google him up and listen to his many speeches made specially in moharram. And to my dear muslism brothers and sisters…please do listen to his majlis on women. For years men have been vaguely telling us what women’s rights are in Islam but this man has been bold enough to right out clear all the misconceptions and give the status to women which Allah has given us. Get informed making emotional statements.

  15. Nazish said

    Get informed before making emotional statements

  16. Nazish said

    Salam

    Dr.Kalbe Sadiq is not only a brilliant well read scholar but a bold one who is not afraid to speak out the truth. Google him up and listen to his many speeches made specially in moharram. And to my dear muslism brothers and sisters…please do listen to his majlis on women. For years men have been vaguely telling us what women’s rights are in Islam but this man has been bold enough to right out clear all the misconceptions and give the status to women which Allah has given us. Get informed before making emotional statements.

  17. Anonymous said

    Mir Babar Ali Anis

    Mir Babar Ali Anis (Urdu: میر بابر علی انیس) was a renowned Urdu poet. He was born in Faizabad in the northern Indian state of Uttar Pradesh in 1803 and died in 1874.

    His father, Mir Khaliq who was a famous poet and litterateur, took personal interest in the education and upbringing of his son, and entrusted him to the care of reputed contemporary teachers, Mir Najaf Ali Faizabadi and Maulvi Hyder Ali Lucknavi. In addition, Anees’s mother who was an educated and pious lady, played a significant role in shaping the personality of the boy poet. But above all, it was the boy’s own instinctive urge for learning and literature that made him an accomplished poet, proficient in Arabic, Persian and Islamic scriptures, and well-versed in logic, literature and philosophy. Poetry came to him as ancestral heritage, for his forbears, going back to his great grandfather, were eminent poets and men of letters. Anees was the grandson of Mir Hasan who is remembered for his immortal Masnavi, Sehir-ul-Bayaan. His parents had migrated in their old age to Lucknow, where he spent the best part of his life.Anees had started writing poetry quite early in his life right at Faizabad, though he perfected his art in Lucknow under the supervision of Imam Baksh Nasikh. In keeping with the popular trend, he first tried his hand at the ghazal, but failing to make much headway in this sphere, he changed over, under the advice of his father, to the writing of marsias, in which domain he soon established a high reputation, equalled (sometimes) by his poetic compare, Salamat Ali Dabir. Anees broadened the scope of this genre by including in its body, in addition to the customary lamentation and mourning, realistic scenes of the battlefield, graphic delineations of the hero’s face and figure, lively portrayals of the emotional states of the combatants, accurate descriptions of the landscape, and occasional interludes of moral edification. Anees was a master of simple, natural utterance, with a superb command on the language, which was always adequate to express a large variety of moods, scenes, characters and situations. He is specially notable for presenting the same scene or situation, over and over again, in different words or phrases, without letting it appear monotonous. Besides being a master of the marsia, Anees was also a specialist of the rubai, the shortest complete poem in Urdu, containing only four lines.Anees died in 1874 at the age of 71.Brief Note on the Marsia: The marsia, strictly speaking, is an elegiac poem written to commemorate the martyrdom and valour of Hazrat Imam Hussain and his comrades of the Battle of Karbala. In its form the marsia generally consists of six-line units, with a rhyming quatrain, and a couplet on a different rhyme. This form found a specially congenial soil in Lucknow (a city in Northern India), chiefly because it was the centre of Shia Muslim community, which regarded it an act of piety and religious duty to eulogise and bemoan the martyrs of the battle of Karbala. Marsiya (Marsia, Marsiya-Khwani, or Soazkhwani) (Persian: مرثیہ) is an elegiac poem written to commemorate the martyrdom and valour of Hazrat Imam Hussain and his comrades of the Karbala. In its form the marsia generally consists of six-line units, with a rhyming quatrain, and a couplet on a different rhyme. This form found a specially congenial soil in Lucknow (a city in Northern India), chiefly because it was the centre of Shia Muslim community, which regarded it an act of piety and religious duty to eulogise and bemoan the martyrs of the battle of Karbala. The form reached its peak in the writing of Mir Babar Ali Anis. Marsia is a poem written to commemorate the martyrdom of Ahl al-Bayt, Imam Hussain and Battle of Karbala. It is usually a poem of mourning. The famous marsia writers in Urdu are Mir Babar Ali Anis, Salamat Ali Dabeer, Syed Muhammad Mirza Uns Syed Sajjad Husain “Shadeed” Lucknavi, Dr. Syed Ali Imam Zaidi, Gauher Luckhnavi the (great grand son of Mir Baber Ali Anees) and Even a short poem written to mourn the death of a friend can be called marsia. Lord Alfred Tennyson’s poem ‘In Memoriam’ can rightly be called marsia. The sub-parts of marsia are called noha and soz which means lamentation and burning of (heart) respectively.At this time in Lucknow Mir Anis’s (Great Grand son)Dr.Syed ali Imam Zaidi(Gauher) Lucknavi recited mersiya on that pulpit. The Majlis of 25 Rajab, very important Majlis of Mersiya in lucknow, in this majlis Mir Anis recited the Mersiya,after that well known mersiya writers of Mir Anis’s family as Dulaha sahab (Uruj),Mustafa Meerza Urf Piyarai sahab (Rasheed),Ali Nawab (Qadeem)Syed Sajjad Husain (Shadeed)after the Syed Sajjad Husain (shadeed)Dr.Syed Ali Imam Zaidi(Gauher) Luckhnavi(grand son of shadeed)recited self composed Mersiya in this Majlis, at the time of Mir Anis this Majlis organised in (Dil-Aram-Baradari) but now a days this Majlis organised in Imam Bara Nazim saheb, Victoria Street, Lucknow.U.P.India.by Syed Sibtey Husain Naqvi(Jauher)Luckhnavi.Dr.syed Ali Imam Zaidi(Gauher)lucknavi is very good(Mersiya and Masnavi, Slam Qata,Rubai,Nazm,Gazal,Nazm) composer and he is a very good translator also. He translate several religious books from Urdu to Hind, as (Quran Majeed), (Wazaiful-Abrar), (Tohfatul-Awam), (Chaudha sitarai), (Quran and Science), (Tafseer-e-Karbala), (Hayat-bad-az-Maut) (Husain ka balidan), (Alia)(Gauhar-e-aza) (Guldastai-Salam) etc.

    SHAJRA
    ——
    (Dr.Syed Ali Imam Zaidi(Gauher)Luckhnavi)
    Meer Gulam Husain(Zahak)
    +
    Meer Hasan Dehlvi
    +
    Meer Ahsan(Khulq)———-Meer Musthsan(Qhaleeq)——–Meer Ahsan(Maqhlooq)
    +
    Meer Baber ali”Anees”–Meer MeherAli(Uns)—Meer Nawab ali(Munis)
    +
    Askari(Rais)-(Khursheed ali(Nafees)(Mohd.Salees)-Three(Daughters)
    + +
    Daughter————-Weds———–Syed Mustafa Meerza(Rasheed)
    +
    Daughter
    +
    Daughter——————–Syed Sajjad Husain (Shadeed)
    +
    (S.Gulam Raza Naqvi)-(S.Sibtey Husain Naqvi(Jauher)(Zeenat Begam)
    + + +
    (Fahmeeda) (Wajahat Husain Naqvi)(Itrat Fatima) +
    +
    Dr.Syed Ali Imam Zaidi(Gauher)—-(Shameem Begum)-(Salaiha Begum)
    + + +
    (Wasiya Zaidi)(S.Ali Imran Zaidi)(Sadaf Zaidi)+ + (S.Gulam Abbas)(S.Khadim Abbas)(Naheed Fatima)(Mahe Tilat(Arshi+
    (Rizvi) +
    (Kaneez Alia)(Farheen)

    ——————————————————————————–

    By:- Dr. Syed Ali Imam Zaidi “Gauher” luckhnavi.
    390/49, Rustam Nager (Near) Masoomiya Masjid,
    Lucknow.226003.U.P.India
    E.Mail: rustamzaidi@yahoo.com Mobile No:9415469481

    —————————————————————–

    (1)Qata
    —-

    “Anees” Ker gai pur Noor, Aftabe sukhan
    unhi ke dam sai huai lakh inqilabe sukhan
    “Anees” hi ne to Urdu ko ker diya Urdu
    unhi ki fikir sai kamil hui kitabe sukhan
    (GAUHER Luckhnavi)

    (2)Qata
    —-
    ujrae huai gulshan ko sawara “Anees” Nae
    iss dubti kashti ko ubhara “Anees” Nae
    Urdu ki mamlaikat main tha, tufan her tarf
    Taigaie zaban sai maraika mara “Anees” nae (GAUHER Luckhnavi)

    (3)Qata
    ——–
    Khushnudie qalbe Abutalib Hain “Anees”
    Quran Bhi hai jis sai mukhatib hain “Anees”
    maddahe ali, zakire shabbir, bhi hain
    maglub hain sab jis sai who galib hain”Anees”
    (GAUHER Luckhnavi)

    (4)Qata
    ——-
    “Anees” Jane sukhan wajhae iftikhare sukhan
    “Anees”sanae gulzare pur bhare sukhan
    kie hain khalq mazameen naw ba naw wallaha
    hai rast go jo kahe unko kirdigare sukhan
    (GAUHER Luckhnavi)

    —————————————————————–

    By:- Dr. Syed aliImam Zaidi Gauher Luckhnavi
    (Great Grand son of Meer Baber Ali “Anees”)
    —————————————————————–

  18. sadaf zaidi said

    salaam

    i completely agree with dr kalbe sadiq who has drawn a poignant picture of islam in his lecture every one knows that he is a brilliant scholar of our community and what he has said is the present condition of our community .several of mullas are a hypocrite they did not give any answer straight forwardly and because of their carelessness several people are going astray and joining other communities.

    sadaf zaidi

  19. QB said

    Salam Sadaf,

    Is the last line your address? Never give too much personal information on internet. There are too many criminals might take advantage. I will edit the last line.

  20. masooma said

    still in search of knowledge and truth

  21. Sajjad Naqvi said

    Dear all,

    My name is Syed Kalbe Sajjad Naqvi. Doctor Sadiq is my Grand Father’s brother…Now I live abroad so frankly speaking I have met him only once or twice….and I was reading this thread I was glad to know that people understand hi message..but there is onething that bothered me..See he is very down to earth and he does not live a very rich life…actually once we came here and he was given a cheque after his lectures and refused for it…when the people insisted on it he said that donate it to my University..I can saw the whole thing with my eyes…If u want to know more about him then please just ask me…i will try my best to answer ur questions…(if u have any)..

    • Nikhat said

      As salam alu kum,

      May i have the official website of Dr. Kalbe Sadiq saheb??

      I searched but couldn’t find it…I have few queries to make and i think he is the best to answer them..

      I’d appreciate if i can get to any media (his official website, official e-mail etc…) through which i can contact him to get the answers…

      Thanks in advance

    • Ali said

      dEAR Sajjad Naqvi said

      I totally agree with you i would like to speak with you about this matter

      Plz contact me on armomin@gmail.com.

      May allah be peace upon you.

      Thanks,
      -ALi

  22. Abbas said

    m not in the favor of DR. QALB-E-SADIQ nor against him

    m just with the truth,,,
    what i had heard by him is all good for humanity………
    i like him because he never speaks sectarian issues.

  23. [...] Mullahs destroying Islam: Kalbe Sadiq [...]

  24. learnquranonline1 said

    mashallah keep it up is a good site where people could learn more about quran and islam i have also seen a site where people could learn quran online and learn quran with tajweed on http://www.learningquranonline.com
    learn quran online, learn quran

  25. Kamal Raza Haider said

    Dr. Kalb-E-Sadiq Sb qibla is absolutely on right track.

  26. Ali said

    Dr Kalb-e-sadiq
    He is asset of all muslims. I love him with the core of my heart and believe in what he say. Muslims should be proud of him.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

 
Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

%d bloggers like this: